4 Nominees for the Jacksonville Circuit Judgeship Eric Roberson Left Oct. 1 Amid Misconduct Charges: 10 Applied, and DeSantis Has 60 Days
The Duval County Courthouse at 501 W. Adams St. in downtown Jacksonville, home of the 4th Judicial Circuit, where the nominating commission held its Oct. 30 interviews. Photo: Excel23 / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)
JACKSONVILLE, Fla. - Four names are on the governor's desk for the Jacksonville circuit judgeship that Eric Roberson gave up on Oct. 1 while facing state misconduct charges over remarks he made from the bench. The 4th Circuit Judicial Nominating Commission interviewed 10 applicants on Oct. 30 and nominated Nassau County Judge Sarah Bell, 4th Circuit Magistrate Amber Donley, Duval County Judge James Nealis IV and Assistant State Attorney W. Joel Powell, the Jacksonville Daily Record reported Nov. 9. Gov. Ron DeSantis has 60 days to appoint one of them or ask the commission for more names, and his staff will interview the nominees in Tallahassee first.
The 4th Judicial Circuit covers Duval, Clay and Nassau counties, and its circuit judges handle felonies, family cases, large civil disputes and domestic violence injunctions. Whoever is appointed will hold the seat until the next election cycle for it, when the appointee can run to keep it. The vacancy is the second on the circuit bench to be filled by appointment in less than a year, after Nicole Saunders was appointed to a circuit seat early this year, the Fernandina Beach News-Leader reported.
Why the seat is open
Roberson was appointed to the circuit court by then-Gov. Rick Scott in 2017 after two years as a Duval County judge, and he was unopposed for election in 2016, 2018 and 2024, according to a Florida Times-Union account published June 15. On June 11, the Florida Judicial Qualifications Commission filed a notice of formal charges alleging he made inappropriate and prejudicial remarks in several 2025 hearings. The commission's investigative panel found probable cause that he may have violated 11 parts of the Code of Judicial Conduct.
The notice quoted Roberson calling a woman before him an "entitled little snot" and telling her father, "God bless you for not beating the tar out of her," according to Action News Jax, which reviewed the filing. In a separate stalking complaint brought by a woman from another state, he allegedly told her, "There's something seriously off with you," and suggested barring her from Florida. His attorney, Scott Richardson, said in June that Roberson acknowledged his conduct fell below the standard expected of a judge and would cooperate with the commission.
Roberson filed a written answer in July that admitted the quotes were accurate but denied he was advocating violence, and argued he had complied with 10 of the 11 canons cited, according to Action News Jax. He then left the bench effective Oct. 1, the station reported Oct. 13. The Daily Business Review reported the same week that the Judicial Qualifications Commission dropped its charges on Oct. 13 after Roberson agreed not to hold judicial office again, according to a summary of that report in The Florida Bar's daily news digest.
Because the case ended before a hearing panel issued findings, the Florida Supreme Court never ruled on the allegations or on any sanction. The nominating commission's Oct. 21 public notice described the opening simply as the result of "the resignation of Honorable Eric Roberson from his seat on the Circuit Court." Chief Judge Lance Day's chambers at the Duval County Courthouse, 501 W. Adams St., hosted the Oct. 30 interviews.
Who applied and who made the cut
The commission's notice listed 10 applicants in 15-minute interview slots beginning at 8:45 a.m.: Bell, Robert Culpepper, Dominic DeLuca, Donley, Cameron French, Makisha Lester, Nealis, Powell, Mai Tran and Kyan Ware. Each applicant was assigned a commissioner to vet the application beforehand, and the redacted applications were posted online through a link in the notice. The same meeting included the commission's leadership elections, which chose Alan Mizrahi as incoming chair and Robert Harris as vice chair for 2026-27, the Daily Record reported.
| Nominee | Current position | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Sarah Bell | Nassau County Court judge | Appointed by DeSantis in January 2026 to Nassau's newly created second county judgeship; sworn in Feb. 2 in Yulee; former assistant attorney general in Jacksonville |
| Amber Donley | 4th Circuit magistrate | Hears cases referred by circuit judges; no prior nomination noted in the Daily Record report |
| James Nealis IV | Duval County Court judge | Appointed by DeSantis in October 2023 to replace Jonathan Sacks; previously an assistant state attorney in the 7th Circuit since 2015 |
| W. Joel Powell | Assistant state attorney, 4th Circuit | Was among six nominees for a new circuit seat in September 2025 and on a three-name list for the Nassau county seat that went to Bell |
Powell is the only one of the four who has been nominated for a 4th Circuit seat before without being chosen, based on the Daily Record's reporting on the 2025 nominating rounds. Bell and Nealis would each leave a county court vacancy behind if elevated, which would start another nominating process. Donley would move from a magistrate's post, which does not require a replacement appointment by the governor.
What happens next
Under Florida's constitution, the governor must fill a circuit court vacancy from the nominating commission's list within 60 days of receiving it. DeSantis can also send the list back and ask for additional nominees, an option the Daily Record noted in its report. With the list sent to Tallahassee after the Oct. 30 interviews, the 60-day window runs to about the end of December, a week before Gov.-elect Byron Donalds is inaugurated Jan. 5.
The nominating commission's chair for the current cycle is Chanda L. Rogers, whose contact information appears on the Oct. 21 notice. The commission does not announce its vote tallies, and the governor's office typically announces appointments by press release without a fixed schedule. Court watchers in Jacksonville will know the seat is filled when a name appears on the governor's judicial appointments page.
Sources: Jacksonville Daily Record (Nov. 9, 2026); 4th Circuit Judicial Nominating Commission public notice posted by the Governor's Office (Oct. 21, 2026); Action News Jax (Oct. 13, 2026); Florida Times-Union via Yahoo News (June 15, 2026); Daily Business Review (Oct. 13, 2026) as summarized in The Florida Bar Daily News Summary (Oct. 14, 2026); Fernandina Beach News-Leader and Nassau County Record (January-February 2026); Jacksonville Daily Record (Oct. 20, 2023; Sept. 2, 2025); Ballotpedia (James Nealis)
News organizations may republish this story with credit. See our guidelines.
Know someone who'd want to read this? Email it to a friend.
Know which restaurants passed inspection
Get the week's restaurant inspection results every Sunday, This Weekend in Jacksonville every Thursday and each evening's local stories. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.
By signing up you agree to get the Jax Times email newsletter. Unsubscribe anytime with one click.