Duval School Board Puts Off Guns-in-Cars Vote 5-2 and Fires the Baldwin Principal, as 3 New Members Take Their Seats Tuesday
The Duval County Courthouse in downtown Jacksonville. Court records show the misdemeanor charge against the former Baldwin principal was dropped Nov. 5. Photo: Ebyabe / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)
JACKSONVILLE, Fla. - The Duval County School Board has put off a decision on whether adults may keep guns in their parked cars on school property, voting 5-2 on Nov. 9 to send the proposed policy back for another round of revisions. At the same meeting the board approved the termination of Michael Smith, the former Baldwin Middle-Senior High School principal whose arrest in September started the debate. Three new board members take their seats Tuesday, and the policy is not expected back for a vote before January, according to Jacksonville Today.
What the board was asked to approve
The proposal would have changed district Policy 3.40, which bars everyone except law enforcement from bringing weapons onto school property, Jacksonville Today reported. Under the revision, administrators, employees, independent contractors and parents, but not students, could keep a legally owned firearm in a vehicle parked on school grounds, as long as it was secured and not readily accessible, according to News4Jax. The change could also have applied to school-sponsored events such as football games, where parking lots fill with visitors.
Florida law already allows an adult to keep a firearm in a private vehicle if it is securely encased or otherwise not readily accessible for immediate use, under Section 790.25(4) of the Florida Statutes. Section 790.115 extends that vehicle exception to school property, but it also lets a school district adopt written policies that waive the exception for student and campus parking. Duval, Clay and St. Johns have all chosen to prohibit guns in cars on campus, according to Jacksonville Today and the districts' spokespeople quoted in its reporting.
Possessing a firearm on school property outside the exceptions is a third-degree felony under the statute, and a concealed-weapon license holder who violates the rule faces a second-degree misdemeanor. Smith was issued a notice to appear on a second-degree misdemeanor charge of possessing a firearm on school property, News4Jax reported. Duval County court records showed the charge was dropped Nov. 5, and Jacksonville Today reported the dismissal followed his completion of a pretrial intervention program.
The 5-2 vote to pause
Board member Melody Bolduc moved to pause the vote and send the policy back to staff for more work, and the motion passed 5-2, Jacksonville Today reported. Chair Charlotte Joyce and Vice Chair April Carney voted against the delay. Several members said they were concerned and confused by how quickly the item had moved from an October workshop to a final vote, and members of the public asked the board to reconsider.
Joyce, who is term-limited, said "I really wanted to vote on it tonight," according to Jacksonville Today, and Nov. 9 was her last meeting. Carney argued that staff should not lose the ability to protect themselves at work, News4Jax reported. Board member Cindy Pearson took the opposite view, saying "I don't think it is going to make our school safer," and she questioned whether guns in cars during sporting events would create a safer atmosphere.
Bolduc asked how often someone has actually left a school building, retrieved a gun from a vehicle and threatened someone, according to News4Jax. Pearson also asked how often vehicle break-ins occur in school lots and whether allowing guns in cars could create a new security problem. District officials said they plan to review weapons-related incidents from the past five years with school police and the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office before the policy returns.
Superintendent Christopher Bernier has not changed his public position since September. "At no time is it safe for anyone to be on our campuses with a gun," he said at a news conference after Smith's arrest, according to both outlets. In a text to board members reported by Jacksonville Today, he said that under district protocols, handgun cases involving employees will likely result in dismissal.
How the Baldwin case unfolded
On Sept. 15, Duval County School Police received an anonymous tip that Smith had a gun in his truck at the Baldwin campus in western Duval County, according to both outlets. Police Chief Jackson Short and another officer met Smith at the school, and Smith declined to consent to a search, News4Jax reported. After a weapons-detecting dog named Maverick gave two positive alerts, he allowed officers to search the truck.
Officers found a Sig Sauer P226 .40-caliber handgun in the center console, in a cloth holster with a loaded 13-round magazine, according to News4Jax. Smith was removed from campus and reassigned to home during the criminal and district investigations. Jacksonville Today reported that the tip came the week after it published details from Smith's personnel file, which the district said contained one substantiated complaint from 2016 and two that were not substantiated, none involving weapons.
Smith had been named principal only months earlier, after former principal Michael Townsend was arrested in June on a charge of failing to report suspected child abuse, News4Jax reported. The board's termination action cited the district's gun policy and state administrative codes that call on educators to "strive for professional growth" and to "exercise the best professional judgment and integrity," according to Jacksonville Today. Bernier and two other district leaders are running Baldwin on an interim basis while the district looks for a permanent principal, and Bernier said the district is also reviewing its hiring process.
Who decides next
Three new members join the board Tuesday, Nov. 17. Donovan Bradley won the District 2 seat vacated by Carney with about 53% of the vote, Rhodesia Butler won District 4 with 50.6% to replace term-limited Darryl Willie, and Lindsey Denmark won District 6 with about 53% to replace Joyce, according to Jacksonville Today's election coverage. Under Section 100.041(3)(a) of the Florida Statutes, school board terms begin on the second Tuesday following the general election, which this year falls on Nov. 17, and Section 1001.371 requires the board to hold its organizational meeting and elect a chair on that date in an election year.
| Step | Date |
|---|---|
| Gun found in principal's truck at Baldwin | Sept. 15 |
| Board workshop on the policy change | Oct. 1 |
| Criminal charge dropped | Nov. 5 |
| Board votes 5-2 to pause the policy; principal terminated | Nov. 9 |
| New board members seated, chair elected | Nov. 17 |
| Possible vote on revised policy | January 2027 at the earliest |
The board is expected to review the revised policy at a workshop later this month, and Jacksonville Today reported it could return for a vote as soon as January. By then the three members who replaced Carney, Joyce and Willie will have had a chance to weigh in. Board meetings are held at the district headquarters at 1701 Prudential Drive, and agendas are posted on the district's website before each meeting.
Sources: Jacksonville Today (Nov. 11, 2026; Nov. 3, 2026; Sept. 30, 2026); News4Jax (Nov. 9, 2026, updated Nov. 10, 2026); Florida Statutes 790.115, 790.25, 100.041 and 1001.371 (2026)
News organizations may republish this story with credit. See our guidelines.
Know someone who'd want to read this? Email it to a friend.
Know which restaurants passed inspection
Get the week's restaurant inspection results every Sunday, This Weekend in Jacksonville every Thursday and each evening's local stories. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.
By signing up you agree to get the Jax Times email newsletter. Unsubscribe anytime with one click.