Know Your Neighbor: Fernandina Beach High's Sarah Twardy, Nassau's Teacher of the Year and 1 of 5 Florida Finalists Out of 74
A historic brick storefront on Centre Street in the Fernandina Beach Historic District. Photo: Ebyabe / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)
FERNANDINA BEACH, Fla. - Sarah Twardy said she couldn't believe it when Superintendent Kathy Burns called her name from the stage at The Ritz-Carlton, Amelia Island, in January. The Fernandina Beach High School social studies teacher had just been named the Nassau County School District's Teacher of the Year, the News-Leader reported. Four months later, the Florida Department of Education named her one of five finalists for 2027 Florida Teacher of the Year, picked from 74 district teachers of the year across the state.
Twardy is the first subject of Know Your Neighbor, a new weekly Jax Times feature about the people and small businesses that make Northeast Florida home. Her year has included a gala crowd, a school fundraiser in her honor and a trip through the state's top teaching competition. Through all of it, the way she describes her job has stayed simple: she wants history to feel alive for the teenagers in her classroom.
A big night on Amelia Island
The district's Teacher of the Year Awards were held on a Friday night at The Ritz-Carlton, the Nassau County Record reported in a Jan. 20 story, which puts the gala on Jan. 16. Twardy stood on stage with four other finalists: Suzy Opalinski of Fernandina Middle School, Elizabeth Taylor of Wildlight Elementary, Karen Russell of Hilliard Middle-Senior High and Deetra Duncanson of Yulee Middle, according to the News-Leader. The evening, presented by the Nassau Education Foundation, raised $180,000 for students, foundation Executive Director Susan DeVane told the crowd, far above the $43,825 the foundation had asked for.
"It was an honor for me to be up there and a humbling experience," Twardy told the News-Leader outside the ballroom after her win. She said the district and her school had several incredible teachers, and she was struck by the support around her. "I can't believe there's so much support for the community from our neighbors, the businesses here and just everybody who wants to support our schools and our students," she said.
Making history come alive
Twardy has spent 19 years in education, according to the district, and teaches 11th-grade U.S. History and Leadership, the News-Leader reported. The state describes her as the lead U.S. History and Government teacher at Fernandina Beach High. "I like to make history come alive for students and teach them it's an exciting experience, and not just words on a textbook," she told the paper.
She said she wants students to feel heard and to think critically, and that she enjoys teaching them about their own place in history, according to the News-Leader. Burns, the superintendent, said in the state's May 7 announcement that Twardy's "inquiry-based approach encourages students to think critically, ask meaningful questions and connect historical learning to their roles as active citizens." Burns also said Twardy is "focused on ensuring every student feels support and inspired to succeed."
The results show up in the numbers, according to the Florida Department of Education. The department credits her instruction with a 92% pass rate on the U.S. History End-of-Course exam, the highest in the school's history. She also mentors future teachers as a clinical educator who supervises their classroom practice, and she holds a bachelor's degree in social studies and a master's degree in U.S. history, the department said.
Coach, parent and guest of honor
Twardy's ties to the school go beyond her classroom, the News-Leader reported. She coaches track, and she has three children in the Nassau County school system. That makes her a teacher, a coach and a school parent in the same community at the same time.
The Fernandina Beach High School Foundation also honored her as its 2025-2026 Teacher of the Year at its Annual Feast on Feb. 7 at Walker's Landing on Amelia Island, the Fernandina Observer reported. The sold-out event drew about 200 guests, featured food prepared by the school's culinary students under Chef Michael Gass and raised more than $140,000, more than double the year before. The foundation supports more than 1,000 students at the school through teacher grants and other projects, according to the Observer.
On the state stage
In its May 7 announcement, the state said finalists were chosen from more than 170,000 public school teachers, with a committee of teachers, principals, parents and business leaders reviewing each district winner's application. "Educators who lead with purpose and an unwavering commitment to excellence create meaningful impact far beyond their own classrooms, and Sarah Twardy exemplifies this every day," Commissioner of Education Anastasios Kamoutsas said in the release. The winner serves for one year as the Christa McAuliffe Ambassador for Education, representing the department and teachers throughout the state.
On July 22, the department named Kyndall Brown, an agriculture teacher at Harmony Middle School in Osceola County, as the 2027 Florida Teacher of the Year. Twardy finished as one of the five state finalists and the only one from Northeast Florida, according to the department's finalist announcements. Nassau's previous Teacher of the Year, Kayla Hooper, told the January gala crowd that the experience had been "life-changing" because she met educators from all over the state, the News-Leader reported.
Know a neighbor worth a story?
Know someone in Jacksonville, the Beaches, St. Augustine, Orange Park or Nassau County who deserves a moment in the spotlight? Send a shout-out at jaxtimes.com/shout-outs with their name and what makes them special, and your neighbor could be featured in a future Know Your Neighbor. To catch every weekly profile, sign up for the free Jax Times newsletter at jaxtimes.com/newsletter.
Sources: News-Leader, Nassau County Record (Jan. 2026); Fernandina Observer (Feb. 11, 2026); Fla. Dept. of Education (May 7, July 22, 2026)
News organizations may republish this story with credit. See our guidelines.
Know someone who'd want to read this? Email it to a friend.
Know which restaurants passed inspection
Get the week's restaurant inspection results every Sunday, This Weekend in Jacksonville every Thursday and each evening's local stories. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.
By signing up you agree to get the Jax Times email newsletter. Unsubscribe anytime with one click.