Politics

St. Johns County Audits Its 157,134 Nov. 3 Ballots Thursday, After Nassau and Clay: How Florida's 7-Day Post-Election Audit Works

Green Cove Springs city hall. Clay County's elections office and canvassing board are based in Green Cove Springs.

Green Cove Springs city hall. Clay County's elections office and canvassing board are based in Green Cove Springs. Photo: Michael Rivera / Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

ST. AUGUSTINE, Fla. - The St. Johns County Canvassing Board will meet Thursday at 11 a.m. to audit the ballots cast in the Nov. 3 general election, the last of the three surrounding counties to run the check that Florida law requires after results are certified. The public audit will be held at the Supervisor of Elections office at 4455 Avenue A, Suite 101, in St. Augustine, according to a notice signed by Supervisor of Elections Vicky Oakes. Nassau County's board was scheduled to audit its ballots Monday afternoon in Yulee, and Clay County's board was scheduled to do the same Tuesday afternoon in Green Cove Springs.

The audits are separate from recounts, which happen only in close races. An audit is a routine test of the voting equipment itself, and Florida requires one after every election unless a manual recount has already been done. It is meant to show that the scanners that counted ballots on election night produced the same totals as an independent count.

What Florida law requires

Section 101.591 of the Florida Statutes gives each county canvassing board two ways to run the audit, according to the law as posted by the Florida Legislature. The first is a public hand count of one randomly chosen race in at least 1% and no more than 2% of the county's precincts, with at least one precinct counted. The second is an automated audit that uses a separate, independent tabulating system to recount every race on the ballot in at least 20% of randomly selected precincts.

The law sets a firm clock. The audit must be finished and its results made public by 11:59 p.m. on the seventh day after the election is certified, and the boards in all three counties scheduled certification for Friday, Nov. 13. Each board must also send the Florida Department of State a consolidated report by Dec. 15 that covers the audit's accuracy, any discrepancies, their likely causes and any recommended fixes.

The three counties' schedules and numbers

St. Augustine Sailing (sponsored) Sponsored
St. Augustine Sailing (sponsored) Sponsored

All three counties use an independent audit system, and their published canvassing board schedules show election staff scanning ballots into that second system throughout early voting and the days after the election. The official results posted on each county's election results site list the totals below. The audit dates come from each board's public notice or schedule.

CountyAudit date and timeBallots castTurnoutPrecincts
NassauMonday, Nov. 16, 2 p.m., Yulee50,82761.94%18
ClayTuesday, Nov. 17, 4 p.m., Green Cove Springs93,78960.4%48
St. JohnsThursday, Nov. 19, 11 a.m., St. Augustine157,13464.43%55

In St. Johns County, the canvassing board is made up of County Judge Alexander R. Christine Jr., who serves as chair, County Commissioner Clay Murphy and Oakes, according to the board's Nov. 13 agenda. That agenda listed three tasks before certification: a final canvass of overseas mail ballots that arrived within the 10-day window, scanning mail ballots into the independent audit system and certifying the official results. The county had 243,889 registered voters for the election, according to its official results.

Nassau County's board is made up of Judge Jenny S. Higginbotham, County Commissioner Klynt Farmer and Supervisor of Elections Janet H. Adkins, according to the county's amended canvassing board schedule. The schedule says the board meets at the James S. Page Governmental Complex at 96135 Nassau Place in Yulee and that the office uses a system called Clear Audit for audits and any recounts. The office's website says Nassau audits 100% of its ballots by scanning the paper ballots a second time through an independent system and comparing those totals with the election night results.

Clay County's board is made up of Supervisor of Elections Chris H. Chambless, County Judge Raymond Forbess Jr. and County Commissioner Timothy Collins, with Judge Hector Murcia-Bustos and Commissioner Kurt Musser as alternates. The board's published schedule lists the session at the elections office at 500 N. Orange Ave. in Green Cove Springs as a "Mandatory Audit (if no Manual Recount)." Like the other two counties, Clay listed ballot scanning into its independent audit system on many canvassing days from mid-October through certification.

What the summer audits found

The August primary gives a sense of what the reports look like. In Nassau County, the canvassing board's Aug. 24 audit compared 24,565 ballots, representing 177,023 marked ovals, against the election night tabulation, according to the board's minutes. The comparison found 16 discrepancies, an accuracy rate of 99.99%, and the board signed the state's post-election audit report form.

In Duval County, the summer audit of the primary and special general elections confirmed "100% accuracy," Supervisor of Elections Jerry Holland said, according to an Action News Jax report published Sept. 1. That audit was a manual hand count of the Democratic primary for Commissioner of Agriculture in Precincts 210 and 1206. Judge Bateh, a member of the canvassing board, picked the two precincts at random, the station reported.

Why Duval may skip this round

Duval's situation is different this month. The Duval canvassing board completed both a machine recount and a manual recount in the tied Atlantic Beach Commission Seat 4 race, News4JAX reported Nov. 10. Under the same state law, a canvassing board that conducts a manual recount is not required to perform the post-election audit, and the notices reviewed for this story did not say whether Duval will run one anyway.

Canvassing board meetings are open to the public, and the St. Johns schedule says board activities are open to candidates, political committee representatives, the press and the public. Residents who want to watch Thursday's audit can go to the elections office on Avenue A, and the state law requires each county to make its audit results public within the 7-day window. Questions can go to the St. Johns County Supervisor of Elections office at 904-823-2238.

Sources: St. Johns, Nassau and Clay canvassing board notices (Nov. 2026); Fla. Stat. 101.591; Action News Jax (Sept. 1, 2026); News4JAX (Nov. 10, 2026)

Read next · Community St. Johns County Libraries Take $2 Off Overdue Fines

News organizations may republish this story with credit. See our guidelines.

Know which restaurants passed inspection

Get the week's restaurant inspection results every Sunday, This Weekend in Jacksonville every Thursday and each evening's local stories. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.

By signing up you agree to get the Jax Times email newsletter. Unsubscribe anytime with one click.

Own a Jacksonville business? Introductory ad rates from $125/month. See ad options Follow Jax Times on FacebookLocal news, events and people, in your feed every day. Follow

Most read this week

  1. 4 Nominees Named for Jacksonville Circuit Judge Vacancy
  2. 13 Have Filed for Jacksonville Mayor: Who's Raised What
  3. Baptist South Adds $30 Million Heart Surgery Unit for Fall 2027
  4. Black Friday Mall Hours for Jacksonville and St. Augustine
  5. Riverfront Plaza Phase 2: Beer Garden, Restaurant and Swing Deck