Local

Leslie McCray's Killer Gets 4 Consecutive Life Terms, Nearly 41 Years After the 17-Year-Old Was Taken From Her Avondale Duplex

The Duval County Courthouse in downtown Jacksonville, where the case was tried and sentenced.

The Duval County Courthouse in downtown Jacksonville, where the case was tried and sentenced. Photo: PicoOrdinalo / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. - Glen McCray never learned who killed his daughter. He died in 2003 at age 62, and on Wednesday, Nov. 18, a relative, Travis McCray, stood in a Duval County courtroom and read a statement from Leslie McCray's aunt, Iris Skeen, explaining what he had asked of the family. "It was his dying wish that we continue to look for the person who took her from us," the statement said, according to News4JAX.

At the same hearing, Judge Meredith Charbula sentenced David Nelson Austin to four consecutive life terms for the 1985 kidnapping, sexual assault and murder of the 17-year-old. The sentence closes a case that sat unsolved for decades, until DNA from a swab taken at her autopsy pointed to a man who had once lived in her duplex. It comes nearly 41 years after she was taken from her home, a span that outlived both of her parents, and it was driven by a family that kept asking investigators to look again.

A night on St. Johns Avenue

McCray was a University of North Florida student who hoped to become a model, according to Project: Cold Case, the Jacksonville nonprofit that took up her case. She lived in a duplex on St. Johns Avenue in the Avondale area with her 20-year-old boyfriend, who was also her roommate. Around 3 a.m. on Dec. 24, 1985, he woke to find an armed man by the bed, was tied up, and the intruder took McCray from the apartment, Project: Cold Case says.

The roommate freed himself and reported her missing around 6 a.m., the nonprofit says. About three hours later her body was found on Old Middleburg Road near a power substation, roughly 5 miles from her home, according to Project: Cold Case; News4JAX described the spot as a ravine. She had been sexually assaulted and stabbed, with a fatal wound to the neck.

Police doubted the roommate's account at first because there were no signs of forced entry, Project: Cold Case says. He remained a person of interest for decades until DNA cleared him, News4JAX reported. After the October verdict he said, "I am grateful for the evidence that led to this guilty verdict."

St. Augustine Sailing (sponsored) Sponsored
St. Augustine Sailing (sponsored) Sponsored

The family kept calling

The family asked investigators to retest the evidence in 2003, but the technology of the time did not produce usable results, according to News4JAX. Glen McCray died that same year. In 2019 the family went back to the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office Cold Case Unit and Project: Cold Case, and detectives found a DNA sequence on a swab from McCray's autopsy sexual assault exam.

That DNA led to Austin, who had been serving a life sentence in Michigan for sexual assault since 1991, six years after McCray was killed. The Sheriff's Office announced his arrest in August 2021, and he was later extradited to Jacksonville, Project: Cold Case says. Leslie McCray's mother died in 2023 without seeing the case resolved, according to the nonprofit.

Austin, 65, was tried in October without a jury, so Charbula alone weighed the evidence. On Oct. 22 she found him guilty of first-degree murder, two counts of armed kidnapping and one count of armed sexual battery, according to News4JAX and Action News Jax. The State Attorney's Office had waived the death penalty before trial, a point noted by Jacksonville defense attorney Gene Nichols, who was not involved in the case.

The sentence

First-degree murder carried a mandatory life sentence, and under the law in effect in 1985 Austin would be eligible for a parole review after 25 years, News4JAX reported. Charbula added three more life sentences, one for each of the other convictions, and ordered all four to run consecutively. She also denied a defense motion for a new trial, and the sources did not say where Austin will serve the Florida sentence.

Austin, represented at trial by attorney Joshua Beard, spoke before he was sentenced. "I would like to express my deepest sympathies to Miss McCray's family," he said, adding that he hoped they could "find a measure of peace." The family had asked for something else, with Skeen's statement telling the court, "We ask that you would show him the same mercy that he showed her, which was none."

What the family carried

Skeen's statement also spoke of the years the family lost waiting for an answer. "We were cheated out of that," it said, according to News4JAX. First cousin Joey Bray said Austin "took part of this family's heart and soul," and said McCray "was robbed of that life just as we were."

Bray has credited Sheriff's Office Cold Case Detective Harmoni Brooks, and Assistant State Attorneys Lauren Anderson and Chyna Makarowski prosecuted the case. Anderson said the family's calls are what moved the case forward. "They picked up that phone, and that caused a spiral of events that ultimately led us here," she said, adding, "It is a blessing that the family was persistent."

Sources: News4JAX (Oct. 22 and Nov. 18, 2026); Action News Jax (Oct. 22, 2026); Project: Cold Case (updated 2026)

Read next · Local Coastal Flood Warning for the St. Johns River Until 7 a.m. Sunday

News organizations may republish this story with credit. See our guidelines.

Know which restaurants passed inspection

Get the week's restaurant inspection results every Sunday, This Weekend in Jacksonville every Thursday and each evening's local stories. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.

By signing up you agree to get the Jax Times email newsletter. Unsubscribe anytime with one click.

Own a Jacksonville business? Introductory ad rates from $125/month. See ad options Follow Jax Times on FacebookLocal news, events and people, in your feed every day. Follow

Most read this week

  1. 4 Nominees Named for Jacksonville Circuit Judge Vacancy
  2. 13 Have Filed for Jacksonville Mayor: Who's Raised What
  3. Riverfront Plaza Phase 2: Beer Garden, Restaurant and Swing Deck
  4. Black Friday Mall Hours for Jacksonville and St. Augustine
  5. Thanksgiving Day 2026 in Jacksonville